The root sum square or rss or statistical tolerance stack up method is useful for doing the assembly tolerance chain stack up analysis of an assembly with large numbers of components in it. Variation analysis case study cummins engine sigmetrix. Tolerance analysis, synthesis and optimization of a dimensional chain using the arithmetic wc worst case method, possibly the statistical rss root sum squares method. My series of posts on worstcase, root sum square, and monte carlo tolerance analysis started off as just a brief introduction to the basics. Tolerance design has become a very sensitive and important issue in product and process development because of increasing demand for quality products and the growing requirements for automation in manufacturing. It is used to calculate the cumulative effects of part tolerances in an assembly. Tolerance analysis an introduction tolerance analysis is a name given to a number of approaches used today in product design to understand how imperfections in parts as they are manufactured, and in assemblies as they are put together, affect the capability of a product to meet customer expectations. Stay on one part until all tolerances are exhausted. As the precision of the machining process increases, the tolerance get reduced but no practical machine can. Worstcase answers the question, if i take the maximum range on each input, what is the maximum range for. Tolerance analysis methods vortarus technologies llc. You will learn about the three basic tolerance analysis approaches with enough detail to get started today. This chapter presents tolerance stack up analysis of dimensional and geometrical tolerances. Determine the 100% tolerance stackup in an assembly.
Tolerance stack up analysis is very useful for calculating tolerance in assembly. Extended statistic analysis of dimensional chain using the 6. A simple new tolerance analysis model suitable for designers is described as. The individual variables are placed at their tolerance limits in order to make the measurement as large or as small as possible. Mortensen 11 presented a compliant assembly analysis method in which statistical tolerance analysis approach was integrated with fem, and multisource covariance was included in the analysis model. The first thing youll want to think of is the bell curve. What is tolerance analysis and why its important steen. We have seen many methods of calculating the worst case tolerance limits for electronic circuits. Root sum square rss unlike the previous method, root sum square rss assumes the certainty. What is tolerance analysis dimensional control systems. Assembly tolerance chain stack up analysis can be performed in many ways.
It helps manage the risk in your project and is the one tool to use when your assembly has more than one stackup. It has an impact on cost, performance, and quality which requires a requisite amount of study to ensure tolerances result in a successful design that can be effectively manufactured. The worst case method of the stack up analysis is the simplest. The root sum squared rss method is a statistical tolerance analysis method.
Assembly tolerance stackup analysis is used for calculating the tolerance value of the overall assembly or a gap in the assembly from the tolerance values of the individual components. Solidworks tolanalyst frequently asked questions q. It will show how to set up a loop diagram to determine a nominal performanceassembly value and four tech. Did you know you have a tolerance analysis tool in solidworks. Methods include 2d tolerance stacks, 3d monte carlo simulations, and datum conversions. You may recall the bell curve being used to explain that some of your classmates were smart, some were dumb, but most were about average. In many cases, the actual individual part dimensions occur near the center of the tolerance range with very few parts with actual dimensions near the tolerance limits. As mentioned previously, the short answer for why tolerance analysis. Apr 10, 2017 tolerance stackup understanding statistical tolerance analysis worstcase analysis vs rss rootsum squared statistical analysis in a worstcase analysis, each dimension will have a minimum and maximum value that represents the range of acceptability for that dimension. The result will be a part fully defined with dimensions and tolerances according to the requirements of asme y14. The statistical variation analysis model takes advantage of the principles of statistics to relax the component tolerances without sacrificing quality.
It is an information packed course that will provide participants with the analytical tools needed to. Step 2 identify all dimensions and tolerances that contribute to the gap. Monte carlo analysis in excel a design tool for the. This allows you to quickly start making tolerance analyses, including the statistical method as described here. Each tolerance in the stack is the rss for the dim. A comparison of tolerance analysis methods by steven m. Pdf tolerance analysis of mechanical assemblies with. The following sections discuss the traditional worst case, rss, and mrss models.
The scope does not include studies on fixture assembly and multisetup tolerance stack up. This model predicts the maximum expected variation of the measurement. Tolerance analysis is a course that is presented through lecture, demonstration, discussion, and written exercises. Analysis of new non traditional tolerance stack up conditions. The disk thickness variation within tolerances is described by a distribution. Tolerance stack up analysis for angularity of components. Tolerance analysis analyze and document geometric tolerances directly on 3d cad models variety may be the spice of life, but wideranging variation in physical dimensions, properties or space between parts is the last thing you want when the components of your product must fit together correctly. Rss tolerance chain stack up analysis learn how to. Tolerance analysis is the process of taking known tolerances and analyzing the. Precise calculation of surface sensitivities exposes the criticaltoquality dimensions in the assembly. Tolerance analysis is a valuable tool for reducing manufacturing costs by improving producibility. Worstcase tolerance analysis is the traditional type of tolerance stackup calculation. In this quicktol video tutorial, you will learn how to construct the basic elements of a tolerance analysis.
Tolerance analysis is an integral part of the engineering process. The below table shows the comparative analysis between worst case, rss, mrss and monte carlo using the example of figure 4 simple example of the loop. The simplest method is the worst case method, which we are going to discuss here. Tolerance stackup understanding statistical tolerance analysis worstcase analysis vs rss rootsum squared statistical analysis in a worstcase analysis, each dimension will have a minimum and maximum value that represents the range of acceptability for that dimension. This tool or process allows designers to increase manufacturing tolerances of parts and assemblies thus reducing costs.
The reasoning is based on worst case or arithmetic tolerancing. The leading tolerance analysis solution what is it. Variousdistributionsovertolerancerange normal density c 1 uniform density c 1. Tolerance analysis is the process of taking known tolerances and analyzing the combination of these tolerances at an assembly level. This paper presents modified relations for worstcase and rootsumsquare rss tolerance accumulation models for tolerance analysis of mechanical assemblies with asymmetric tolerances. Enventive concept takes tolerance analysis of mechanical engineering designs to another level by making analysis the cornerstone of a more effective and efficient design cycle rather than relegating tolerance analysis to an isolated task performed in the late stages of product development, enventive takes a holistic approach to mechanical engineering design that seamlessly combines tolerance. Start at the bottom and work up, or start at the left and work to the right. Tolerance analysis seeks to make design changes as early as possible in the product lifecycle, where they are the least expensive.
Datum reference frame position and shape tolerances tolerance. In this article we will discuss worst case and rss methods to solve tolerance stack up problems. Analysis of new non traditional tolerance stack up. However, theres much more to tolerance analysis than that.
Tolerance analysis of 2d and 3d assemblies automated method kenneth w. Technical drawing 101 with autocad channel 154,3 views. This chapter will define the process for analyzing tolerance stacks. Jul 26, 2016 understanding probability density functions pdfs and a quick introduction to the different types of distributions commonly useful for the monte carlo approach. Engineering and industrial services tolerance analysis. Step 1 identify the requirement that is to be analyzed. Tolerance stackup analysis is a design tool used to analyse and optimize product design for assembly. Tolerance analysis of assemblies promotes concurrent engineering by bringing engineering. Monte carlo analysis in excel a design tool for the component. Tolerance stack analysis methods are described in various books and papers, see for example gilson 1951, mansoor 1963, fortini 1967, wade 1967,evans1975,cox1986,greenwoodandchase1987,kirschling. So now we complete a rss calculation with the 2 dims. Enventive writes tolerance analysis reports to an integrated microsoft excel spreadsheet that is bidirectionally associative with the enventive model, providing a familiar and flexible view of the results for designers, systems engineers, mechanical engineers, manufacturing engineers, and engineering managers. The control over the tolerance numbers can be found in the tools, options, document.
An example is provided to illustrate the bdam application. Spreadsheet for tolerance analysis mikedevries automotive 22 oct 03 08. Rss tolerance chain stack up analysis learn how to perform. The histogram, summarizing these thicknesses, is often assumed to be. Statistical worst case design analysis allows each component to be at its minimum or maximum value and then, based on the interaction of the individual components, computes the minimum and maximum expected performance values. The application of this model gives very loose tolerance and hence a lower manufacturing cost. Statistical tolerancing assumption statistical tolerancing assumes that disks are chosen at random, not deliberately to make a worst possible stack, one way or the other. Utilizing advanced mathematical solutions, this tolerance analysis solution accelerates design improvements to achieve robust designs ready for. Beginning with the two extreme cornerstones, namely the arithmetic or worst case tolerance stack and the statistical or rss tolerance stack. Since then i have heard from a number of you asking for a clear, concise everything else out there is so heavy. The intent of this paper is to demonstrate several different methods, and determine the results, and the corresponding confidence factors for each method.
Worstcase tolerance analysis is dependent on how parts are actually assembled in real life it is incorrect to think max worst case is when the parts are at their largest and min worst case is when they are at their smallest part nominal assembly worstcase maximum worstcase minimum. Its methods may be used on other types of systems subject to accumulated variation, such as mechanical and electrical systems. In this article we will look at tolerance analysis methods, and their pros and cons. Tolerance analysis is an important part of mechanical design. Tolerance analysis is the general term for activities related to the study of accumulated variation in mechanical parts and assemblies.
Pdf this paper presents modified relations for worstcase and rootsumsquare rss tolerance accumulation models for tolerance analysis. Tolerance analysis, in general, has two main approaches worst case and statistical, rss root sum of squares first being more conservative and latter being more optimistic and relying on individual process capability knowledge. Tolerance analysis carried out at the time of design is a manner of translating design intention into statistically rooted model. The tolerance analysis equation for the rss stackup condition is given as. You can then use the tolerances with tolanalyst to perform stack analysis on assemblies, or with downstream cam, other tolerance analyses, or metrology applications. Traditional approaches to analyzing mechanical tolerance stacks. All the machining process produces the components within certain amount of tolerance to its desired dimensions. Calculating a fit between and cylinder and a hole duration. Tolerance stack up analysis is often used to make sure that the cumulative effects of the tolerances are acceptable to the functional aspects in an assembly. A tolerance stackup analysis is an analysis used by designers and engineers to determine if an assembly of parts will fit together and function properly.
Chase mechanical engineering department brigham young university provo, utah 1. The same principle holds true in tolerance analysis. Several useful methods of selecting design tolerances are presented with examples. Jan 14, 20 relationships between dimensional tolerances. In short, assembly tolerance stack up analysis will tell you the tolerance value of the whole assembly or a specific gap of the assembly when you know the tolerance values of all its components. In the case 1 all dimensional inputs were left as normal distribution and in the case 2, the dimension value 60 was changed for uniform distribution. Statistical tolerance analysis basic introduction accendo. You need to delve into the world of root sum square rss tolerance analysis. That process of randomizing and adding the random parts is called a montecarlo analysis.
Analysis of a dimensional chain deformed as a result of temperature change. Tolerance stack up analysis for angularity of components and. The model conveniently predicts the loss the design would yield, or a quantitative representation of parts rejected when compared with the total yield thereby resulting in dissatisfied customers. Statistical tolerance analysis based on beta distributions citeseerx. Tolerance analysis worstcase worstcase tolerance analysis is the traditional type of tolerance calculation. In this approach, a systematic analysis for estimating process capability levels at the design stage is used in conjunction with statistical methods. The analysis is based on the dimensioning scheme of the individual parts and how they are assembled. Worst case wc and root sum square rss have been used. This, of course, assumes the parts are mostly centered and within the tolerance range.
1477 25 232 484 1319 1166 1080 175 862 1287 707 1172 421 1363 693 899 231 492 1273 343 1128 46 920 82 1142 148 1070 483 964 1524 91 814 1083 1306 290 865 764 692 1164 1262 659 147 1227 351 591 138 673